Homeland's
workers left defenseless
By HELEN THOMAS
President Bush will get
his Homeland Security Department, but federal workers from 22
agencies will lose much of their job security.
That's the sorry deal.
Senate Democrats, who before the Nov. 5 election had resisted the
legislation creating the department because of its weak worker
protections, read the election results and saw the handwriting on
the wall. Bush expects to sign the legislation by Thanksgiving after
the Senate gives its go-ahead in a few days.
It is incredible that the president was so determined to weaken
the Civil Service system that he delayed the formation of the
department for months because of one hang up: He wants to hire and
fire workers at will.
Under the legislation he now will be free to exempt unionized
workers from collective bargaining in the name of national security.
And here we thought that domestic terrorism was supposed to be
the issue and the basis for a new Cabinet-level department -- the
first major government reorganization since World War II.
The GOP-controlled House passed the legislation in July along the
lines proposed by the White House. But the sticking-point delaying
Senate passage was the Democrats' insistence on protecting workers'
rights.
Bush had sought a relaxation of the civil-service rules affecting
the employees in the new department, hoping to cripple their unions.
As a sop to the Democrats, the latest compromise would require
the department to negotiate workplace changes with the employees
union and would be required to submit to federal mediation if no
agreement was reached. But the department would have the last say on
whatever it wanted.
Three centrist senators -- Ben Nelson, D-Neb., John Breaux, D-La.
and Lincoln D. Chafee, R-R.I. -- broke the stalemate with
concessions so lopsided in favor of the administration's goals that
it would be laughable to call it a compromise. They acknowledged
that they rolled over.
Breaux told reporters: ``The agreement falls short of what we
originally suggested as the way to protect the workers of the new
agency.
''But we knew it would pass regardless of what we did. So we
tried to get something in it that would at least give unions a
hearing'' before a mediation board.
Senate Majority leader Tom Daschle said that he disagreed with
the personnel provisions in the bill but would not block it.
Some 170,000 government workers who will be moved into the
department, like it or not, can say goodbye to the protections they
have known in the past.
It is yet another indication that the president and his
administration made up of CEOs see a golden opportunity to undermine
labor unions. They also have little understanding of the long
struggle of government workers to obtain the rights and benefits
they attained under Civil Service.
The cherished Civil Service system was created in 1883 as a
result of the politicization of government employees -- federal jobs
handed out because of political connections, cronyism and nepotism.
Though many presidents, Republican and Democratic, have referred to
those on the federal payroll disdainfully as ''bureaucrats,'' most
Americans know that they are dedicated career public servants who
make the government run. Creation of the new Department of Homeland
Security is a big victory for Bush, who made it one of the
centerpieces of his campaign along with the relentless attack
against Iraq.
He can also add to his political laurels the defeats of Sens. Max
Cleland, D-Ga. and Jean Carnahan, D-Mo. -- both of whom had voted
against the pending legislation in order to protect the rights of
government workers. It was hardly a proud moment in American
political history when Cleland, who lost two legs and an arm in the
Vietnam War, was denounced as unpatriotic for holding out against
the bill for the sake of organized labor.
Bobby L. Harnage, president of the American Federation of
Government Employees (AFGE), denounced the latest version of the
bill.
''The American public needs to know that the president's
so-called compromise bill for the Homeland Security Department is a
Trojan horse. It may be called ``homeland security'' but it has
nothing to do with improving security. All it does is strip workers
of the right to defend themselves in the workplace.''
Harnage called it a ''terrible piece of legislation'' that
``gives the president the power to strip unionized workers of their
ability to represent themselves on matters as basic as hiring,
firing, promotions, appraisals, disciplinary actions, matching pay
to job duties -- the bread and butter of democratic unionism.''
The new department will include the Secret Service, the Coast
Guard, the Customs Service, the Federal Emergency Management Agency
and some divisions of the Immigration and Naturalization Service.
Going nowhere is a sensible proposal in the bill by Sen. Joseph
Lieberman, D-Conn., to create an intelligence division in the new
department that would analyze raw intelligence about terrorist
threats collected by the FBI and CIA.
The FBI and CIA are not about to give up their powerful
sovereignty. When Bush gets his intelligence briefings, he still
sees CIA director George Tenet and FBI director Robert Mueller
separately.
The new department will take many months to function smoothly.
And while it is designed to give Americans a greater sense of
security on the homefront, the administration's insistence on
jettisoning workers' rights is bound to make them more insecure.