Call from lobbyist rattles lawmaker
A BellSouth vice president spoke at length
to a Miami legislator voting on the House floor, prompting
questions about the way the telecommunication industry lobbies.
BY MARC CAPUTO
TALLAHASSEE
- As Florida lawmakers tried to freeze the largest
telephone rate hike in state history, a top-ranking official at
BellSouth made an alarmed call to a lawmaker on the House floor --
shaking up the legislator so badly that it outraged his
colleagues.
The caller: Eliseo ''Tito'' Gomez, a BellSouth vice president
and lobbyist. On the other end: Rep. Julio Robaina, a Miami
Republican and a veteran BellSouth employee.
Gomez pressured Robaina so hard into voting against the measure
that the lawmaker ended the phone call flustered and teary-eyed,
lawmakers familiar with the conversation told The Herald.
''It's despicable what BellSouth put one of its employees
through. It's absolutely disgraceful they brought that man to
tears under the pressure they put him through,'' said Rep. Manny
Prieguez, R-Miami. ``I have never seen a member put through the
grinder the way he was by BellSouth and Tito Gomez. Absolutely
despicable, despicable. Horrible. BellSouth should reevaluate its
relationship with [Gomez].''
Gomez, a Miami political insider with strong ties to County
Hall, denied putting undue pressure on the lawmaker.
The call, however, clearly perturbed Robaina, who changed his
vote three times. Robaina, who has worked for BellSouth for 24
years installing phone lines, would not talk about the content of
his conversation with Gomez, saying he didn't want to ''pick a
fight'' with anyone.
''I was very distraught because I am an employee of the
company. But at the end of the day, I voted my conscience. I feel
very good about my final vote,'' said Robaina, who ultimately
supported the rate-hike freeze.
Several other legislators who spoke with Robaina after the
conversation with Gomez labeled the call ''arm-twisting.'' They
said they were outraged by the company's behavior, but not
surprised considering the high-pressure lobbying techniques
employed by the telecommunications industry.
''They put pressure on him to toe the company line. They
twisted his arm pretty hard,'' said Rep. Juan Zapata, R-Miami, who
voted against the freeze. ``I don't know if he threatened him with
his job. I just know they put a lot of pressure. The fact is, it's
not a secret he works for his company. Your employer is telling
you to do something. If you don't do something, what do you think
could happen?''
Gomez told The Herald on Tuesday that he never made any
threats, veiled or otherwise. He said he was just ''advocating''
BellSouth's position as he does with any legislator, and that
Robaina's employment with the company would not be affected by the
way he votes.
The call lasted so long that Robaina was off the House floor
and missed the March 31 vote entirely. When he asked the House
clerk to record his vote after the fact, Robaina said he was so
bothered that he accidentally voted for the measure.
After Gomez called him again, Robaina said he switched his
''yes'' vote to a ''no.'' Then House leaders spoke to Robaina
about the measure and explained its merits, he said. He then
switched his vote back to yes. In the end, the measure passed
70-47, according to the House's daily session journal, which
reflects the rare and erratic voting by Robaina.
After the votes, Robaina groused to Prieguez as well as
Miami-area state Reps. Gaston Cantens and Gus Barreiro, all of
whom voted to freeze the hike. Each said he felt that the
representative was under pressure that wasn't called for.
''To me, what happened with Robaina just crosses the line,''
Barreiro said. ``It isn't acceptable for one of our colleagues to
be put in that position. Tito crossed the line. It was
unacceptable.''
The legislation the phone companies oppose would freeze rate
hikes the Legislature approved last year, when the companies
pumped more than $5 million into political campaigns and parties.
The companies won the rights to seek a rate increase of almost
$350 million. But the measure has been challenged in court,
leading House Speaker Johnnie Byrd to attempt to repeal it this
year. Facing opposition, Byrd then proposed a measure to
temporarily freeze rates until the Legislature can look at the
matter next year.
When the freeze came up for a vote before the full House last
week, the telephone companies went to work. They had already made
sure the measure was dead in the Senate, as they continued to peel
representatives away from Byrd.
On the day of the vote, Gomez said he called Robaina on the
House floor to get a sense of the lawmakers who were ''sitting on
the fence.'' Gomez said Robaina ``is someone we have a very close
working relationship with.''
This is the second time Gomez, 57, has run into controversy
recently.
For three years, the U.S. Attorney's Office has been
investigating a payment of $1 million that a contractor at Miami
International Airport made to Gomez's wife as part of a
minority-fronting scheme. The investigation centers on whether the
money was actually meant to buy her husband's political influence.
Gomez's attorneys have denied any wrongdoing, and say
investigators are misguided.
Gomez -- BellSouth's main in-house lobbyist in Florida --
conducts extensive political polling, and plays a key role in
deciding which legislators the telecommunications giant will
support.
Gomez said he guessed Robaina's colleagues misinterpreted his
calls to a lawmaker who was deeply conflicted over the issue.
Herald staff writers Joe Mozingo and Gary Fineout contributed
to this report.